As it happens, the United States, under the Trump administration’s tenure, finds itself in rather a pickle, not unlike what occurred in China some decades ago. Many a Chinese soul looks upon the happenings in America with a sense of déjà vu. It’s a tad reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution, or “the decade of turmoil” as it’s oft dubbed.
Contents
Reflections of the Past: The Cultural Revolution
During the Cultural Revolution, China endured unfathomable hardships. Millions perished, and tens of millions faced persecution (source). Under Mao Zedong’s leadership, young zealots, known as the Red Guards, were charged with dismantling the bureaucracy. A notion eerily reminiscent, some might say, of the changes ushered in under the Trump administration.
Parallels in Policy and Power
Amongst Chinese nationals, there are whispers: it’s a bit like when Xi Jinping engineered a constitutional change to secure a third term (source). And what to make of Trump’s musings on extending his presidency beyond the normative confines?
Perspectives from Prominent Voices
For instance, Wang Jian, a seasoned journalist, penned on X: “Dictatorship is not just a system; it’s the pursuit of power.” These sentiments resonate as he casts a critical eye on Trump, drawing comparisons with Mao’s tactics during the Cultural Revolution.
The Changing Image of the United States
The United States once aided China in modernising its economy. The hope was that China might become more democratic and open. Now, some Chinese folks perceive the U.S. as becoming more akin to China’s own political machinery (source). “Beacon of democracy, 1776-2025,” quipped a netizen on Weibo, in response to an official U.S. Embassy post.
Social Media: A Stage for Expressing Discontent
Weibo, China’s equivalent of Twitter, is abuzz with lively discourse. The US Embassy’s account, once a bastion for U.S. values, now finds itself inundated with disillusioned commentary. “You betrayed Ukraine!” one user exclaimed, addressing American policy regarding the Eastern European nation.
The American embassy’s Weibo account used to advocate for truth about American culture, countering Chinese state narratives.
Leadership and Loyalty: A Recurring Theme
Back in the day, Mao Zedong had a penchant for surrounding himself with loyal but often unqualified followers, a leadership style Xi Jinping echoes. The parallels don’t end there. When the U.S. Embassy announced selective media access to White House press events, a user likened it to tactics familiar to an authoritarian regime (source).
Erosion of Democratic Values
There’s a shared anxiety about America’s current tumult. Zhang Qianfan, a law professor at Peking University, remarked, “The only way to dismantle America’s ‘deep state’ is through a ‘Cultural Revolution.’" But revolutions, cultural or otherwise, seldom yield the fruits of fairness or efficiency.
Conclusion
Much like a rippling echo through time, the past and present reveal unnerving similarities between the East and West. Although the United States and China stand as distinctly different nations, the lessons of history caution against unchecked power and the erosion of democratic ideals. In this unfolding narrative, both countries continue to write chapters that resonate deeply with observers worldwide.
