All else is never equal when it comes to markets

You ever stroll down Wall Street or catch a glimpse at CNBC, and it feels like you’re playing dodgeball with bad news? I swear, it happens almost every day. We’re talking economic data, geopolitical dramas, inflation creeping up, interest rates climbing the ladder, natural calamities, and just about anything that can throw a wrench in the market’s gears. And let’s not forget about tariffs, wars between international buddies, and viral outbreaks that send a ripple of fear through investors.

Now, let’s say you hear about oil prices shooting up. Sounds like a downer, right? But ceteris paribus — this trusty Latin phrase meaning "all else equal" — it’s what analysts tell themselves when they examine the effects of one particular nuisance. Rising oil prices mean lower earnings due to costlier energy. But what if, out of the blue, those high prices signal red-hot economic activity? You might actually start ringing the register faster than anticipated, overcoming those pesky energy bills.

This philosophical nugget makes you think twice. It’s like when the Fed toys with the idea of interest rate cuts. Fewer cuts, ceteris paribus, might sound bearish. But hey, if better-than-expected economic data keeps rolling in, it doesn’t matter. Stock prices continue their upward march.

Goldman Sachs painted a perfect picture back in June 2023 when talking about AI’s game-changing potential: The S&P 500’s tax rate might need to hit 28% in 20 years’ time to offset earnings boosts from AI, everything else being unchanged! Meanwhile, JPMorgan chimed in last September with a similarly astute observation about buyback taxes and earnings per share. The point is, nothing happens in a vacuum.

Consider tariffs, for instance. When President Trump threw around the term, it wasn’t just hot air. Tariffs are no joke — they can shackle economies. Analysts like Savita Subramanian from BofA gave us the lowdown, suggesting hefty tariffs like the 25% on Canada and Mexico when combined with a 10% sprinkle on China, could shave off a definite chunk from earnings. But once again, the all-powerful "all else equal" rears its head, reminding us of the unseen forces and counteractions at play.

And yet, many companies are nimble, skirting around these additional costs, often exceeding earnings expectations. So, while there’s endless chatter about challenges, don’t lose sight of the silver linings, which might just bolster stocks.

Let’s reel in some numbers to get a better picture:

  • Unemployment Claims: Slipped to 213,000 last week. Shows some grit from the economy.
  • Retail Sales: Dropped 0.9% in January, but wildfires and frosty weather didn’t help.
  • Inflation: CPI in January nudged up to 3.0% year-over-year. At this rate, it ain’t losing steam.
  • Gas Prices: Ticked up a couple of cents to $3.13 per gallon. Blame tariffs for that one.
  • Mortgage Rates: Inched down to 6.87%, lighting a spark under prospective buyers.

Economic outlook? It’s a mixed bag of jitters and optimism. Housing remains resilient, with most homeowners shielded from fickle interest rates. Meanwhile, small businesses feel a bit energized and industrial activity climbs, even as office spaces sit mostly empty during the midweek.

Now, let’s drift north for a sec. With GDP growth in Q1 estimated at 2.3% by the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow model, there’s reason to stay optimistic. But as they say, Wall Street is a beast of many moods. Analysts reckon the stock market could outperform the broader economy thanks to companies going lean and mean, slashing costs, and embracing tech, especially AI.

But here’s the kicker. Don’t plant yourself too firmly on either side of the boat. The landscape teems with uncertainties — political kerfuffles, global tensions, surprise economic nosedives — you name it. As always, strap in for recessions and volatile market swings. It’s part and parcel of playing the market.

This optimism isn’t just fluff. The economy and the markets have shown time and again their ability to thrive after taking a few gut punches. So, while there might be storms brewing on the horizon, the march forward continues, unwavering as ever. Long-term investors: keep your eyes on the prize.